Journal sections
Archive and statistics
Log in



or
Печатный вестник PRINTED
JOURNALS OF
MRSU
Издательство МГОУ Publishing house the
MRSU
CONTACT US:

Our address: 105005, Moscow, Radio street,10a, office 98.

Telephone:
+7 (495) 780-09-42 add. 1740,
+7 (495) 723-56-31

E-mail: info@evestnik-mgou.ru,
e-mag@mgou.ru

Work schedule: Monday to Thursday from 10-00 to 17-30,

Friday from 10:00 to 16-00,

lunch break from 13:00 to 14-00.

 

WE IN SOCIAL MEDIA

BK Facebook Telegram Twitter Instagram

Bulletin of the MRSU / Section "Politics" / 2020 № 2.

 

V.O. Beklyamishev

WORLD WAR II, “SPANISH FLU” OR CHERNOBYL? COVID-19 PANDEMIC IN THE MIRROR OF HISTORICAL ANALOGIES (BASED ON USA AND RUSSIAN MEDIA-DISCOURSE). In: Bulletin of the Moscow Region State University (electronic journal), 2020, no. 2.

Doi:10.18384/2224-0209-2020-2-1002


UDC Index: 32.019.51

Date of publication: 13.05.2020

The full text of the article

Downloads count Downloads count: 82

Abstract


Purpose. The article attempts to reconstruct a range of historical analogies used to describe the COVID-19 pandemic in American and Russian public discourse in March 2020. Methodology and Approach. The methodological framework is set by the tradition of collective memory research (“memory studies”). The source base is materials posted on official websites of “The New York Times”, “The Washington Post” and “The Wall-Street Journal”, as well as materials from the Russian-language media discourse selected by search queries in the “Yandex News”. Results: the analysis of the media discourse allowed the author to identify three types of appeals to the collective past: “military”, “economic and “epidemiological” analogies. It is noted that the repertoires of “military” and “epidemiological” analogies in Russian and American media discourse are almost identical. Theoretical and/or practical implications. The study allowed testing the author’s methodology for the analysis of historical analogies in the media discourse, and its results open perspectives to further study of the problem.

Key words


pandemic, coronavirus infection, COVID-19, collective memory, historical analogies, «memory studies»

List of references


1. Vasilenko Ju. V. Evristicheskii potentsial istoricheskoi analogii [Heuristic potential of historical analogy]. Available at: www.psu.ru/psu/files/1634/27 Vasilenko.doc (accessed: 01.04.2020).
2. [Global memory: the culture of historical responsibility in the XXI century]. In: Istoricheskaya ekspertiza [Historical examination], 2016, no. 3, pp. 7–10.
3. Krylova M. N. [“Keeping calm like a partisan”. Preceedent comparisons from the sphere of history]. In: Russkaya rech’ [Russian Speech], 2017, no. 6, pp. 31–35.
4. Malinova O. Yu. [Temporality and other properties of the symbolic in politics]. In: Simvolicheskaya politika [Symbolic politics], 2014, no. 2, pp. 5–17.
5. Nestik T. A. Sotsial’naya psikhologiya vremeni [Social psychology of time]. Moscow, Publishing house “Institute of Psychology RAS”, 2014. 496 p.
6. Norman I. Ispol’zovanie «Drugogo»: Obrazy Vostoka v formirovanii evropeiskikh identichnostei [The Use of the “Other”: Images of the East in the Formation of European Identities]. Moscow, 2004. 336 p.
7. Silant’eva V. N. [The Origin of Precedent Texts]. In: Vestnik Altaiskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta [Bulletin of Altai State University], 2010, no. 2 (50), pp. 106–111.
8. Chubar’yan А. О., ex. ed. Teoriya i metodologiya istoricheskoi nauki. Terminologicheskii slovar’ [Theory and methodology of historical science. Terminological dictionary]. Moscow, Akvilon. 2014. 576 p.
9. Chudinov A. P. Rossiya v metaforicheskom zerkale: Kognitivnoe issledovanie politicheskoi metafory (1991–2000) [Russia in a metaphorical mirror: A cognitive study of political metaphor (1991–2000)]. Ekaterinburg, 2001. 238 p.
10. Axelrod R., Forster L. How historical analogies in newspapers of five countries make sense of major events: 9/11, Mumbai and Tahrir Square. In: Research in Economics, 2017, no. 71, pp. 8–19.
11. Brändström A., Bynander F., Hart P. Governing by looking back: historical analogies and crisis management. In: Public Administration, 2004, no. 82 (1), pp. 191–210.
12. Ghilani D., Luminet O., Flassbeck C., etc. Looking forward to the past: An interdisciplinary discussion on the use of historical analogies and their effects. In: Memory Studies, 2017, vol. 10, pp. 274–285.
13. Paris R. Kosovo and the Metaphor War. In: Political Science Quarterly, 2002, vol. 117, no. 3, pp. 424–451.
14. Peckham R. COVID-19 and the anti-lessons of history. In: The Lancet, 2020, vol. 395, iss. 10227, pp. 850–852.
15. Pehar D. Historical rhetoric and diplomacy – an uneasy cohabitation. In: Kurbalija J., Slavik H., ed. Language and Diplomacy. Malta: DiploProjects, 2001, pp. 117–138.

Лицензия Creative Commons