Journal sections
Archive and statistics
Log in

Печатный вестник PRINTED
Издательство МГОУ Publishing house the

Our address: 105005, Moscow, Radio street,10a, office 98.

+7 (495) 780-09-42 add. 1740,
+7 (495) 723-56-31


Work schedule: Monday to Thursday from 10-00 to 17-30,

Friday from 10:00 to 16-00,

lunch break from 13:00 to 14-00.



BK Facebook Telegram Twitter Instagram

Bulletin of the MRSU / Section "Politics" / 2016 № 4.


A.A. Zotkin

THE PROBLEM OF WAR AND PEACE IN THE WORKS OF KANT, FICHTE AND HEGEL. In: Bulletin of the Moscow Region State University (electronic journal), 2016, no. 4.


UDC Index: 32.327.7; 341.24

Date of publication: 29.12.2016

The full text of the article

Downloads count Downloads count: 121


The evolution of war and peace issues in the works of I. Kant, J.G. Fichte, G.W. Hegel, the representatives of German classical philosophy, is introduced in the article. Each of the thinkers, basing on the ideal of “eternal peace” which was characteristic for the Enlightenment era, eventually comes to the conclusion that it is not feasible, at least in the nearest future. The general result of German classics’ reflections on the problem of war and peace was the conclusion about the necessity and inevitability of the legal establishment of international relations, which, while not being an absolute guarantee of peace, promotes the withdrawal from either potential or actual war.

Key words

war, peace, government, politics, law, treaty

List of references

1. Berman G.Dzh. Zapadnaya traditsiya prava: epokha formirovaniya [The Western Tradition of Law: the Era of Formation]. M., 1994. 524 p.
2. Gaidenko P.P. Paradoksy svobody v uchenii Fikhte [The Paradoxes of Liberty in Fichte’s Teaching]. M., Nauka, 1990. 128 p.
3. Hegel G.V.F. Fenomenologiya dukha [Phenomenology of Spirit]. SPb., 2006. 444 p.
4. Hegel G.V.F. Filosofiya prava [Legal Philosophy]. M., 1990. 524 p.
5. Hegel G.V.F. Konstitutsiya Germanii [The German Constitution] // Hegel Politicheskie proizvedeniya [Hegel. The Political Works]. M., 1978, pp. 65–184.
6. Hegel G.V.F. O nauchnykh sposobakh issledovaniya estestvennogo prava, ego meste v prakticheskoi filosofii i ego otnoshenii k nauke o pozitivnom prave [On Scientific Methods of Research of Natural Law, its Place in Practical Philosophy and its Relation to the Science of Positive Law] // Hegel. Politicheskie proizvedeniya [Hegel. The Political Works]. M., 1978, pp. 185–275.
7. Hegel G.V.F. Sistema nravstvennosti [System of Morality] // Hegel Politicheskie proizvedeniya [The Political Works]. M., 1978, pp. 276–367.
8. Hegel G.V.F. Entsiklopediya filosofskikh nauk. T. 3. Filosofiya dukha [Encyclopedia of Philosophical Sciences. Vol. 3. The Philosophy of the Spirit]. M., 1977. 471 p.
9. Gulyga A.V. Gegel’ [Hegel]. M., 1994. 256 p.
10. Gulyga A.V. Kant [Kant]. M., 1994. 304 p.
11. Zotkin A.A. Gegelevskaya kritika «vechnogo mira» I. Kanta [The Hegelian Critique of “Perpetual Peace” by Immanuel Kant] // Vestnik Moskovskogo universiteta. Seriya 12. Politicheskie nauki [Bulletin of Moscow University. Series 12. Political Science], 2010, no. 3, pp. 40–51.
12. Kant I. K vechnomu miru [Perpetual Peace] // Kant I. Sochineniya: v 8 t. T. 7 [Works: in 8 vol. Vol. 7]. M., 1994, pp. 5–56.
13. Kant I. Metafizika nravov [Metaphysics of morals] // Kant I. Sochineniya: v 8 t. T. 6 [Works: in 6 Vol. Vol. 8]. M., 1994, pp. 224–540.
14. Kozhev A. Ideya smerti v filosofii Gegelya [The Idea of Death in Hegel’s Philosophy]. M., 1998. 208 p.
15. Kuznetsov V.N. Nemetskaya klassicheskaya filosofiya vtoroi poloviny XVIII –nachala XIX veka [German Classical Philosophy in the Second Half of the XVIII – Early XIX century]. M, 1989. 480 p.
16. Motroshilova N.V. Kontseptsiya «vechnogo mira» i soyuza gosudarstv I. Kanta: aktual’noe znachenie [The Concept of “Eternal Peace” and Union of States by Kant: Relevance] // Immanuil Kant: nasledie i proekt [Heritage and Project]. M., 2007, pp. 406–427.
17. Nersesyants V.S. Filosofiya prava Gegelya [The Philosophy of Law by Hegel]. M., 1998. 352 p.
18. Oizerman T.I. K voprosu ob osnovnykh ideyakh «Fenomenologii dukha» Gegelya [On the Question of the Main Ideas of the “Phenomenology of Spirit” by Hegel] // «Fenomenologiya dukha» Gegelya v kontekste sovremennogo gegelevedeniya [“The Phenomenology of Spirit” by Hegel in the Context of Contemporary Studies of Hegel’s Heritage]. M., 2010, pp. 152–160.
19. Piontkovskii A.A. Uchenie Gegelya o prave i gosudarstve i ego ugolovno-pravovaya teoriya [The Doctrine of Hegel on Law and State and its Criminal Law Theory]. M., 1993. 480 p.
20. Politicheskaya tekstologiya kak nauka i uchebnaya distsiplina: kruglyi stol / K.M. Anderson, O.Yu. Boitsova, V.A. Varkhotova [Political textual criticism as a science and academic discipline: round table] // SCHOLA-2013: Materialy Mezhdunarodnoi nauchnoi konferentsii Politika v tekstakh – teksty v politike: nauka istorii idei i uchenii» / pod red. A.Yu. Shutova i A.A. Shirinyantsa [SCHOOL-2013: Proceedings of the International Conference “Politics in the Texts – Texts in Politics: the Science of the History of Ideas and Doctrines”, 30–31 October 2013]. M., Izdatel’stvo Moskovskogo universiteta, 2013, pp. 341–357.
21. Popper K. Vremya lzheprorokov: Gegel’, Marks i drugie orakuly [The Time of False Prophets: Hegel, Marx, and Other Oracles] // Popper K. Otkrytoe obshchestvo i ego vragi. V 2 t. T. II [The Open Society and its Enemies. In 2 t. T. II]. M., 1992. 526 p.
22. Fikhte I.G. Rechi k nemetskoi natsii [Speech to the German Nation]. SPb., Nauka, 2009. 352 p.
23. Fikhte I.G. Zamknutoe torgovoe gosudarstvo [The Closed Trading State] // Fikhte I.G. Sochineniya: v 2 t. T. II [Works in two volumes]. SPb., MIFRIL, 1993, pp. 225–357.
24. Fikhte I.G. Osnovnye cherty sovremennoi epokhi [The Main Features of the Modern Era] // Fikhte I.G. Sochineniya v 2 t. T. II [Works in 2 Volumes. Vol. II]. SPb., MIFRIL, 1993, pp. 359–617.
25. Chicherin B.N. Istoriya politicheskikh uchenii. T. 3 [History of Political Doctrines. Vol. 3]. SPb., 2010. 720 p.
26. Shmitt K. Nomos Zemli v prave narodov jus publicum europaeum [The NOMOS of the Earth in the Law of Peoples, the Jus Publicum Europaeum]. SPb., 2008. 669 p.

Лицензия Creative Commons